Reflection & Prayer Prompts
When Relationships Don't Give Back: Unrequited Relationships and Self-Blame
Personal Reflection Questions
Take your time with these questions. You don't need to answer them all at once. Choose one or two that resonate, and sit with them. Honest reflection is more valuable than complete answers.
Looking Back
-
Where have you been "putting money in an empty machine"? Think about the relationships in your life — family, friendships, work, church. Where have you been investing your heart, effort, or hope without receiving much in return?
-
What have you told yourself about why the relationship isn't working? When someone doesn't give you what you need, what's your default explanation? That you're not good enough? That you need to try harder? That if you were different, they'd respond differently?
-
When did you first learn to blame yourself? The pattern of self-blame often starts early. Can you trace it back? Was there a relationship in your childhood where you learned that if things weren't working, it must be your fault?
-
Where has "defensive hope" kept you stuck? Dr. Cloud describes defensive hope as using hope to avoid facing painful reality. Where have you been hoping a person would change rather than acknowledging they may not be capable of giving what you need?
Looking Inward
-
What would it mean to accept that it's not about you? If the problem isn't your lovability or your effort — if the other person simply doesn't have what you're looking for — how would that change how you feel about yourself? About them? About the relationship?
-
What are you afraid of facing? Sometimes we keep trying because the alternative feels too painful: admitting the relationship isn't what we hoped, grieving what we'll never receive, or making hard decisions about our investment. What truth might you be avoiding?
-
What has this pattern cost you? Years of trying to be enough, trying to earn love, trying to finally get through to someone — what has that taken from you? Energy? Joy? Other relationships? Your sense of self?
Looking Forward
-
What would "calling the repairman" look like in your situation? Instead of trying harder, what might it look like to try differently? An honest conversation? Counseling? Setting a boundary? Getting a third party involved?
-
Where else could you find what you're looking for? If one relationship can't give you the love, approval, or connection you need, where else might you find it? Friends? A mentor? A support group? A counselor? Your relationship with God?
-
What would it look like to stop? Not to stop loving, but to stop pouring yourself out. To stop measuring your worth by their response. To stop starving in front of an empty machine. What would you do with that energy instead?
Guided Prayer Language
These prayers are offered as starting points. Adapt them, expand them, or let them lead you into your own honest conversation with God.
A Prayer for Clarity
God, I've been putting money in empty machines for a long time. I've been hoping that if I just tried harder — loved better, performed more, became enough — I'd finally get what I've been longing for.
Help me see clearly. Show me where I've been blaming myself for things that aren't mine to fix. Help me stop measuring my worth by whether difficult people respond well to me.
Give me the courage to face what's real, even when it hurts. And help me trust that you see me, even when others don't.
Amen.
A Prayer for the Grief Underneath
God, I'm beginning to see how much I've invested in relationships that couldn't give back. And underneath my trying, I think there's grief — grief for what I never received, grief for years I can't get back, grief for the love I was always longing for.
Be with me in this sadness. Help me not to rush past it or spiritualize it away. Let me feel what I need to feel, knowing that you are close to the brokenhearted.
I don't know what to do next. But I trust that you do. Lead me toward life.
Amen.
A Prayer for Wisdom
God, I don't want to give up on the people I love. But I also don't want to keep doing what isn't working.
Give me wisdom to know the difference between trying harder and trying differently. Show me what strategies might actually help — conversations, boundaries, counseling, new approaches. And if this relationship truly can't give what I need, help me find other sources of love and connection.
I release my need to make this work on my own. I trust you with outcomes I can't control.
Amen.
A Prayer for Worth
God, somewhere along the way I started believing that my worth depended on whether people responded to me. If I could just be enough — smart enough, good enough, lovable enough — I'd finally receive what I've been longing for.
That was a lie. Help me believe the truth: that my worth was never on trial. That I am loved by you — not because I've earned it, but because you made me and you chose me.
Set me free from the need for approval that someone else can't give. And help me rest in the approval I already have from you.
Amen.
Optional Journaling Prompts
If you find writing helpful, these prompts can guide deeper reflection. There's no right length or format — just write what's true.
Prompt 1: A Letter to Your Younger Self
Write a letter to the version of yourself who first started believing that if relationships didn't work, it must be your fault. What would you tell them? What do they need to hear?
Prompt 2: The Machine That Was Out of Coke
Describe a relationship where you kept "putting in money" long after it was clear you weren't going to get anything back. What were you hoping for? What kept you trying? What did it cost you?
Prompt 3: What I Would Do With the Energy
If you stopped pouring yourself into a relationship that doesn't give back, what would you do with that energy? How might your life be different? What would you have space for that you don't have now?
Prompt 4: The Truth I've Been Avoiding
Write honestly about a truth you haven't wanted to face. Maybe about a person, a relationship, or yourself. You don't have to share this with anyone. Just let yourself be honest on the page.
Prompt 5: What God Might Be Saying
If God were speaking to you about this relationship — not with judgment, but with love — what might he say? Write it as if it were a letter from him to you.
Closing Thought
There's a particular kind of exhaustion that comes from years of trying to be enough. From believing that if you just did more, tried harder, became better — finally, finally — you'd receive the love you've been longing for.
If that's where you are, here's what's true: the machine might be out of Coke. And that's painful. But it's not a verdict about your worth.
You were never on trial.
Take your time with these reflections. Let yourself feel what you feel. Trust that God is with you in this — not demanding performance, not measuring your worth by outcomes, but simply present, patient, and kind.
You can hit the refund button. You can walk down the hall. You can find what you're looking for somewhere else.
And that's not failure. That's freedom.